<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eshaqisani20a</span>
Fabrice P. Lauss𝕪’s ℤoukified Web

Synchronization along quantum trajectories. N. Es'haqi-Sani, G. Manzano, R. Zambrini and R. Fazio in Phys. Rev. Res. 2:023101 (2020).  What the paper says!?

This paper by Najmeh et al. studies synchronisation through the single-trajectory approach, thereby investigating the individual vs the ensemble problem for the particular case of synchronisation, which is interesting on its own. The system itself is that of two dissipatively coupled van der Pol oscillators.

Their master equation:

which they solve as a diffusive stochastic Schrödinger equation.

Note the interesting, and not quite usual, $\mathcal{D}[a_1-e^{i\theta}a_2]$ Lindblad term. This is forcing the phase locking between the oscillators, though. In the analytical solution (5), the average phase $\Delta\phi_\pi$ is indeed locked to $\theta$ (see their Fig. 5b showing this relationship).

They mention that

among different ways of unraveling the master equation dynamics (1), we choose the diffusive approach with continuous measurements of Xk because it best provides information about the oscillators phases. Other approaches like the ones achieved by direct observation of the quantum jumps correspond to the projection of the system state in the product of local Fock basis, thereby leading to a randomization of the oscillators phases. Still, the persistence of signatures of synchronization in quantum jumps would be interesting to explore.

This seems a central point, which is just "pointed out" but probably deserves more attention.

They define two limits depending on the rates:

  • $\gamma_\downarrow^{(i)}/\gamma_\uparrow^{(i)}\to0$ (so-called "infinite photon limit") recovers the classical case.
  • $\gamma_\downarrow^{(i)}/\gamma_\uparrow^{(i)}\to\infty$ (so-called "quantum limit") whose steady state density matrix $\pi$ is a limit cycle (so not when it recovers the classical case?)

They focus on the 2nd case, which can be analytically solved. In this case, apparently, the system is driven into $\ket{0}$ and $\ket{1}$ subspaces of the oscillators. This would correspond to the coupling of two qubits, which is certainly why this is solvable exactly.

Results related to the above statements are apparently from previous works,[1] and they shed further light by looking at it through single trajectories.

They characterize the system with i) the two-oscillator coherence:

ii) the Pearson correlators between the oscillator quadratures:

and iii) the entanglement entropy.

They solve numerically and find that $|C_\psi|$ remains high but $r$ can change a lot, because the phase drifts. Something like this:

They conclude:

trajectories which are actually not phase-locked to θ may instead contribute with a high value to
— Cπ, , giving the (wrong) impression that the

system is synchronized, and therefore spotting the necessity for looking at synchronization indicators beyond average

values

which is a bit unclear. The above case is therefore not synchronized. Note that they don't give the value of $\theta$ in their parameters, although we later understand this is $\theta=0$, and the phase should not lock to it anyway but to the relation

which apparently is also close to $\Delta\phi_\pi=0$.

Then, having shown there is no synchronization, they nevertheless turn

to explore the relation between the emergence of synchronization and the entanglement shared between the two VdP oscillators during single trajectories

which has been done, among others, by Nha and Carmichael[2].

They compute distributions of $|C_\psi|$, the phase $\Delta\phi_\psi$ of $C_\psi$, the Pearson $r$ and the entanglement entropy $S_\psi$, averaged over time, for two cases: poor synchronization (blue) and good synchronization (red), which is decided by the coupling strength.

Their Fig. 3 supposedly shows that synchronization is associated to entanglement, but the nature of this association remains vague: entanglement is more broadly distributed when there is phase synchronization, but it keeps taking mainly small values. Its variance increases (it would be more clear if the variance would remain small but the average entanglement grows!) Since correlations are not causation, it's unclear what they arrive to. They state it in this way:

This statistical correlation for the tails of the distribution provides a link between a purely dynamical phenomenon, namely, synchronization (and in particular phase-locking) with a strong measure of quantum correlations, entanglement, along trajectories.

What is the difference between synchronized oscillators that are entangled, and synchronized oscillators that are not, is however not discussed.

They could have shown a case of strong synchronization (Fig. 1 looks pretty synchronized to me, but by their standard, is not). Some trends, such as Fig. 5(a) opposing the variance of phase difference and entanglement, are strong, but their meaning is unclear.

There is a dark state in their system, which their "dissipative coupling" pumps, so I expect that touching this disconnected state leads to their huge fluctuations, as of course this state brings a lot of entanglement, but is also difficult to get into. This reminds me of our old work on trapping into dark states.[3]

There is a nice summary of the trajectory approach:

The quantum trajectory formalism describes the stochastic evolution of the pure state of the system $\ket{\psi(t)}$, conditioned on measurements obtained from the continuous monitoring of the environment [42,43].

Some interesting references, including:

along with [7-25] on quantum approach to synchronization.

Overall, an interesting look at how single trajectories behave in the particular case of a fundamental feature of nonlinear oscillators, but still with remaining questions. I expect the dark state dynamics would account for the dynamics much more clearly and convincingly than the observations they report (that come with no causation or explanation).

Points of discussion

They ask «whether quantum synchronization may be used for witnessing quantum correlations is still an open question.» But if synchronization is quantum, surely it involves quantum correlations.

They say they work in the limit $\gamma_\downarrow/\gamma_\uparrow\to\infty$ but then they also say that they consider (for simplicity) equal rates in both oscillators: $\gamma_{\uparrow,\downarrow}^{(1)}=\gamma_{\uparrow,\downarrow}^{(2)}=\gamma_{\uparrow,\downarrow}$ and then only use $\gamma_\uparrow$, which is confusing as seemingly incompatible (what they mean is that $\gamma_\downarrow\neq\gamma_\uparrow$ and in the "quantum limit" the result doesn't depend on $\gamma_\downarrow$; they give $\uparrow$ but never $\downarrow$ in their parameters).

The relationship of their work with their Ref. [39], Weiss et al.[4], is unclear and a complete assessment should be made in the light of the previous literature.