Experimental distinction between the quantum and classical field-theoretic predictions for the photoelectric effect. J. F. Clauser in Phys. Rev. D 9:853 (1974).  What the paper says!?

Screenshot 20240625 171503.png


Our experiment thus resurrects the photoelectric effect as a phenomenon requiring quantization of the electromagnetic field.

This is an early paper studying photon cascades, claiming to show quantization of the light field (an important question at this time of Jaynes' neoclassical theory.

Screenshot 20240625 190840.png

In a first section, Clauser shows that previous experimental attempts were not able to show photon quantization. Then he claims to show that himself, with Cauchy-Schwarz violation in coincidences from photon cascades. The source is Hg atoms excited by electron bombardment, so apparently incoherent pumping, with the cascade $9{}^1P_1\to7{}^3S_1\to6{}^3P_1$.

This is the experimental result (seemingly from Clauser alone!):

Screenshot 20240625 192238.png

Panels (a) and (d) show the cascade, (b) and (c) show no correlation (shouldn't it be antibunched?) with the quantum source while (e) and (f) show bunching with the classical source (probably HB effect). The main result is (g) that shows violation of Cauchy-Schwartz inequality and thus that the field is quantized.

Al-Hilfy and Loudon[1] comment on this paper.

References

  1. Theory of photon correlations in two-photon cascade emission. A Al-Hilfy and R Loudon in J. Phys. B.: At. Mol. Phys. 18:3697 (1985).